Peace Sunday 

Pastor Janet Bauman at the pulpit

Romans 12: 9-21 from The Message

Introduction: Playing With Guns

When my son was around 10 years old, he came home from the arena with the news that his hockey team was going paint balling for their end of season team celebration, followed by a pizza party. Paint balling. What I saw in my mind was military style clothing and weapons. Simulated combat. Aggression. The thrill of hunting, and hiding, ambush and “killing” even if the “hits” were only marked with a paint spatter and not with real blood. And I saw my little boy playing war games. It didn’t feel right to me. And so my son and I had some pretty intense interactions about paint balling. 

He made his arguments. He was always good and defending his position on something. It was just a game. It was just for fun. Playing paintball wasn’t going to turn him into some kind of aggressive monster, these guys were his friends, they weren’t going to actually hurt each other,  the other parents were letting their sons play, and if he didn’t get to play he would be left out of the fun. He made a good, strong case.

I made my arguments. Paint balling didn’t look like a game. It looked real. It simulated real combat. It was playing war games. And war was too serious to play as a game. We don’t have toy guns or violent video games in our home, so we are not OK with this either. And just because other people are doing it doesn’t make it right. It ignores the devastating results of war if we play it as a game, and it desensitizes us to the real impacts of war. I thought I made good points too.

Around and around we went. It was a tough conversation. I didn’t want him to be left out. Was I being too strictly ideological? In the end, we didn’t let him play paintball, but took him to the pizza party afterwards. We gave him permission to paint us (pun intended) as the “bad guys” if he needed to. When he got to the door, one of his teammates said, how come you weren’t at paintball? My son’s reply, probably with a generous eye roll, my parents wouldn’t let me. Your parents are dumb! the teammate replied. I am guessing my son concurred, and that was all that was said. Off he went to eat pizza!

Years later, my daughter’s hockey team chose Laser Tag for their year end party. What is it about playing shooter games for kid’s team parties, I wondered! I was one of the coaches this time, so I was expected to be there. Should I allow Laser Tag if I didn’t allow Paint Ball? The premise is pretty much the same (run, hide, ambush, shoot). My argument, lame as it probably sounded to my kids, was that Laser Tag looked less realistic, less like war games than Paint Ball. It was more like Tag, only we could “zap” each other with lasers. And my daughter was older than my son had been when the paintballing came up. I did join in, with my daughter and her team for Laser Tag. Was I being a hypocrite? 

For the record, I was terrible! The girls on the team were zapping me from every angle! There is a score board or sorts at the end and I was pretty much at the bottom! I got zapped so many times and managed only a couple hits myself. But, I must say, it was fun, and everybody seemed to have a good time, so what was the harm? 

One more story. When I was teaching grade 6 at Rockway I took my students to the Laurel Creek Conservation Authority Outdoor Education Centre for a field trip, and some hands-on science learning about animals and habitats. Among other things, we played the Survival Game. All the students were assigned the identity of an animal in the habitat. We had mice, rabbits, squirrels, raccoons, foxes, and I think even a wolf. Their task was to find their food tokens (hidden around the playing area), and find a mate in order to be successful, to survive. They were released into the playing area according to their size and numbers–there were lots of mice and rabbits, and fewer of the animals further up the food chain. The danger was, the small ones could be preyed on by the larger animals that came later, whose survival depended on catching smaller prey as their food source. So they had to be careful! It was a good simulation, and gave the kids a real sense of the precarious nature of life and the food chain.

A while after the wolf had been sent in there was one more predator that got released. It was a human, with a gun. And guess who got to play that role? It was reserved for the teacher! Now, the gun I got was a great big, neon coloured water soaker, and I had to be pretty close to one of my prey in order to shoot them with a stream of water. But despite that, I couldn’t believe the sense of power I got from holding the gun as the apex predator in this scenario. How exhilarating it was, running around that playing area–everyone scattering in fear! And I am humbled to admit how satisfying it was to chase down one of my students, who caused me no end of grief in the classroom, and get him with a blast of water from my super soaker! 

Being a Peacemaker is Complicated!

Why do I share these stories of gun play? Among other things, they remind me that being a peace maker is complicated! It isn’t just something for Sunday morning, when we talk about what it means to follow Jesus. It leaks into our everyday life. How we parent, and how we relate to our friends. How we spend our money and time. What we do for fun. And peace making isn’t some pure, dogmatic ideal. A clear line we can draw that always holds. There are a lot of nuances and grey areas. Many complicating factors depending on the context. So much of it has to be worked out in each new situation. And noticing my exhilaration at having that super soaker water gun made me realize how easy it could be for me to misuse power or resort to violence. So peace making also has to do with looking inward to see what is going on in my own heart. 

It reminds me of the wise words of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyns, A Russian army commander who had both dished out terrible violence and been on the receiving end. In prison he came to this realization: 

Gradually it was disclosed to me that the line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either—but right through every human heart—and through all human hearts. This line shifts. Inside us, it oscillates with the years. And even within hearts overwhelmed by evil, one small bridgehead of good is retained. And even in the best of all hearts, there remains … an unuprooted small corner of evil. https://fee.org/articles/aleksandr-solzhenitsyns-forgotten-lesson-on-good-and-evil/

And so I approach this morning’s service with a posture of humility. This is a complex, complicated topic. We each approach it with our own story, shaped by our experiences and that of our families. Some of you have family immigration stories or personal experiences of fleeing terrible suffering and violence. Some of you have lived and worked in an active war zone. Some of you work with vulnerable populations in our own communities where people’s lives have been shattered by intimate partner violence, substance use disorders, and poverty. Many of us have lived in relative peace and tranquility our whole lives, and can be blind to the way some people are hurt and harmed by systems and structures that shape our world.    

Whatever our experiences, the gift is that we are talking about it, we are wrestling with it, and we are doing it together. 

As I reflect on my own journey into peace making I recognize how sheltered my life has been, and how simple it seemed, at first to be a pacifist. I grew up in a Mennonite home, attending this church, and knowing that Mennonites were opposed to war, that we should refuse to fight in war. My Mennonite ancestors have lived in safety and security here in Canada since the war of 1812 ended. From our Anabaptist heritage in the 16th century came the teaching of non-resistance based on the teachings of Jesus, and the willingness to suffer violence rather than engage in it. No-one in my family was conscripted or enlisted in either World War I or II, so we didn’t have war stories in our family history. We were the people who lived as “the quiet in the land”–simply, unobtrusive, gentle folks who take care of the land and make good farmers and good neighbours. There was a purity and an idealism, a simplicity to my inherited pacifism. 

But over and over again through the years, this pure ideal of what it means to be a peacemaker has been challenged and stretched.

As a teenager, I read Sue Steiner’s book, Joining the Army That Sheds No Blood. Written for teens, it explores what the bible says about peacemaking, and the story of Christian peacemakers through the centuries. It is a call to join an army to “wage peace” instead of war– an invitation to be less passive and more active as a peacemaker. 

I had to wake up to the nature of violence, and how it can take so many forms. It is much more than combat during armed conflict. 

  • In Canada we are called to consider how our country’s foundational colonial history does violence to Indigenous people
  • How trauma and violence have lasting and even intergenerational  impacts 
  • How exclusion and judgment of people who identify as LGBTQ2+ does violence to their identity and sense of self
  • How some people living in poverty while others live with obscene wealth violates our sense of humanity 
  • How pollution, habitat destruction, resource extraction do violence to the land and its creatures. 
  • Perhaps most challenging has been the work of Kim Penner, and before her Carol Penner and Lydia Harder and many others, who have challenged how our peace church tradition has been used. Encouraging and praising women for their gentleness, submission and willingness to suffer has left many of them vulnerable to boundary violations and abuse. Teaching people to forgive, and love their enemies, to absorb violence as Jesus did rather than perpetrate it, has left us ill equipped to deal with power in the church and violence in family settings.

As our understanding of violence has needed to expand, so has our understanding of what it means to be a peacemaker. All of these challenges, and many more have made peacemaking more complicated. 

What Has Happened to the Peace Movement?

I was impressed by the frank and honest conversation we had as a planning committee for this service. The real wrestling with how to take a stance for peace and what that looks like in our times. It was refreshing to hear the questions and the real fear, anger and frustration about what is happening in our world. The heartfelt warnings and stories about the risk of letting our world slip into the kind of authoritarianism that led to the rise of Nazism in Germany. 

We are living in deeply troubling times. We are disturbed by the increasing violence in our world, the ongoing wars and threats of wars. We are troubled by the rise in authoritarianism, hate and discrimination. By the increase in divisions and extremisms. By the accelerated pace of resource extraction even in the face of the reality of the climate crisis. 

And we see a decline in public virtue, civility and decency, leading to a “rupture of the world order” and an “orderless age” according to one writer (David Pfrimmer The Record opinion article; August 26, 2026; MAGA tribe swings its wrecking ball).  Pfrimmer describes public virtue and civility as “foundational assumptions” and underpinnings guiding how we behave and live together.They are “the belief that truth matters, power should be restrained, opponents deserve legitimacy, institutions deserve trust and respect, and citizens have obligations beyond self-interest.” But those have been replaced by what he calls “transactional entitlement” with its me first, greed that is all about taking.

In another article, Pfrimmer writes, “The Red Cross reports that ‘armed conflict is a defining feature of our time,’ with 130 armed conflicts–the most since the Second World War.”, while “the peace consensus…has faded (David Pfrimmer, The Record opinion article, Tuesday, October 6, 2026; Peacebuilding faces cuts as conflicts rise).”

Lloyd Axworthy, former foreign affairs minister, spoke at the 50th anniversary celebration of Project Ploughshares, which works at peace-security research and advocacy and disarmament. He raised the concern that Canada is “scaling back many of its peacebuilding tools”–reducing international aid, cutting the number of peacekeepers, trimming diplomatic staff, and not speaking out as much on human rights issues–while increasing our military spending and arms exports. So, Pfrimmer argues, with “the international peace-supporting architecture…broken” this is “the moment for renewed and revived Canadian peace and “justice-seeking movements” (Pfrimmer, Peacebuilding). 

He recognizes that “a peacebuilding movement during these turbulent, militarized times might feel like Sisyphus’s punishment–constantly pushing the boulder of peace uphill against war, militarism and increasing state violence. Yes, it may roll back. Nonetheless, as civil rights activist Rosa Parks said, ‘We will fail when we fail to try’” (Pfrimmer, Peacebuilding). 

Being a peacemaker today can feel complicated and overwhelming. Where to start? What to focus on. How to be effective? Peacemaking is complex because violence is complex and has many facets. Peacemaking needs to respond to all the ways that violence impacts our world. 

Love Your Enemies

So, in that context, when we first read today’s scripture at our planning meeting it didn’t take long for all of us to express how uncomfortable it made us. Somehow this Scripture seemed too pure, too idealistic, too simple in the face of such big and complicated challenges. And where is the justice, we wondered? In the text forgiveness seemed to be offered too easily. Where is the setting things right, the consequences or punishment for all the evil stuff that is going on?! And where is the honest accounting for all the trauma and pain that has been unleashed? 

This text is part of a letter Paul wrote to a cluster of churches at the heart of the Empire, who lived under the very nose of the Emperor in Rome. These churches were made up of Jewish and non Jewish followers of Jesus. At one point Emperor Claudius expelled all Jews from Rome, including those who were part of the Jesus movement. Five years later when the Jews were allowed to return they found a church that had become very non-Jewish in custom and practice in their absence. This created lots of tension. The Roman church was divided. They disagreed about how to follow Jesus, and about Jewish customs like Sabbath, Kosher foods, and the practice of circumcision as ritual for entry into the faith. 

Paul wrote the letter because he wanted this divided church to become unified, and he hoped a strong, unified church in Rome could be a staging ground for his mission further west to Spain. The letter to the churches in Rome is Paul’s fullest and longest explanation of the gospel of Jesus Christ. In earlier chapters Paul spells out his theology. But in the section we read, he turns to much more practical matters. How to live with each other in this divided church. A church that was bringing together both Jews and Gentiles in God’s family (for this background see the Bible Project https://bibleproject.com/videos/, Video Episodes: Romans 1-4, Romans 5-16).

We chose The Message paraphrase because the language here is especially frank, simple, straightforward and clear: love from the centre of who you are; run for dear life from evil, be good friends, don’t quit in hard times, be inventive in hospitality, bless your enemies, get along with each other, make friends with nobodies, don’t hit back, don’t insist on getting even, discover beauty in everyone, if you see your enemy hungry, go buy that person lunch, if they are thirsty get them a drink, your generosity with surprise them with goodness (excerpts from Romans 12:9-21). 

There are strong echoes here of Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount, and his teachings about anger and enemies and retaliation. The section of the Sermon on the Mount where Jesus asks his listeners to consider previous understandings of the Law: you have heard that it was said… and then challenges, or nuances, or deepens that teaching by saying, but I say to you… (see Matthew 5:21-48). You have heard that it was said, you shall love your neighbour and hate your enemy. But I say to you, Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you (Matthew 5:43-44). 

Both Paul and Jesus ground their teachings on peace, unity, justice, mercy, and forgiveness, compassion and generosity on their experience of the nature of God. We are called to reflect God’s character in the ways that we relate to each other. When we share and show love we are orienting ourselves toward God. When we share and show hatred in its many forms we are orienting ourselves away from God. 

Peacemaking: Start Within, Start Small

It reminds me of the tale of two wolves that an Indigenous elder told his grandson. A grandfather, passing his teachings to his grandson, told him the tale of two wolves to explain our human behaviours. You see, son, he said, there are two wolves doing battle inside each of us. One wolf is full of anger, resentment, guilt, lies, greed, envy, arrogance and regret. The other wolf is full of love, joy, peace, hope, kindness, generosity, truth, and compassion. 

The same fight is going on inside you, grandson…and inside of every other person. The boy was troubled by this image of such a battle in each of us. And he thought about this story for a long time. Finally, he turned back to his grandfather and asked, “Grandfather, which wolf wins?” The grandfather’s reply was, the one you feed.

It would seem that many in our world are feeding the nasty wolf. We know who our enemies are and if we see only enemies, we see only hatred, harshness, and nastiness, and we end up creating more of it. 

But apparently there is an extension to the tale of the two wolves. In this ending, when the grandson asks the grandfather which wolf wins the grandfather replies, If you feed them right they both win. To feed only one wolf would starve the other and it would become even more fierce and angry and uncontrollable. But feed them both and there will be no more battle inside. To feed the nasty wolf is to show it compassion and mercy. It means to listen to why it is so angry. To show it understanding.To feed and care for both means they will serve you well. And when there is no more battle going on inside of you, you can listen to the voices of deeper wisdom, and trust them to guide you into choosing the right path. 

So what are we being called to as peacemakers? On one hand it is complicated. There are so many ways that violence affects people in our communities and in our churches. How do we respond to all of that?! It can feel overwhelming to face all that violence. Where does one start?! If we are too fixated on how complex the problems are we can spin our wheels trying to get traction. We can freeze with indecision, we can feel inadequate, ill equipped, we can become despondent or even indifferent because we can’t figure out what is ours to do. 

As individuals we are not going to solve all the intractable problems of our world. Trying to do everything is a recipe for burnout. But giving up is not an option. Let me offer two simple places to start.

Start by taking an honest look within. At the battles that go on within your own heart. At the wolf within and its resentment, and guilt and regret. How righteous anger can turn to bitterness. How a hunger for change and the tools to make change happen can turn into a hunger for power over others. How a thirst for justice can turn into a thirst for revenge.  Show that nasty wolf within compassion and mercy to understand why it is so bitter and angry. And when there is no more battle going on inside, then you can listen to the voice of deeper wisdom to find the path that is yours to take. 

And start small. Marcia’s suggestion for the song to sing at the end of the service captures it beautifully. Let there be peace on earth. Here is the big, complicated, complex challenge that can feel overwhelming. And let it begin with me. Here is the simple way to begin. Start small. Start with what you can do. Start with what you are good at. I am amazed at all the peacemaking gifts and skills we have right in this congregation. Peacemaking can start local. Hyper local. With the way we treat the people we encounter everyday, in our neighbourhoods, our workplaces, our schools, our church, our family. Be inventive in hospitality. Surprise them with goodness, as Paul writes. And God will multiply the blessing. 

Scroll to Top